Family outraged by racial makeup of jury in Arbery slaying

UniqueThis 14 November 4, 2021

Family members of Ahmaud Arbery expressed outrage Thursday after the judge in the trial of three white men accused of killing the Black man said there was nothing he could do about the racial makeup of the jury.

Superior Court Judge Timothy Walmsley in Georgia acknowledged Wednesday there "appears to be intentional discrimination" when looking at how the jury of 11 white people and one Black person was selected.

The family's attorney, Benjamin Crump, said Thursday that Arbery "is again denied justice," and he found it "outrageous that Black jurors were intentionally excluded to create such an imbalanced jury."

Arbery's aunt, Thea Brooks, said she wasn't surprised by the outcome.

"It's just another injustice that we face daily," she said on MSNBC, adding that she remains hopeful jurors will be open-minded.

Race and bias are central issues in Arbery's death. Greg McMichael and his adult son, Travis McMichael, armed themselves and pursued Arbery in a pickup truck after they spotted him running in their neighborhood. A neighbor, William "Roddie" Bryan, joined the chase in his own truck and took cellphone video of Travis McMichael shooting Arbery three times with a shotgun, authorities said.

Defense attorneys for the McMichaels and Bryan have said they committed no crimes. Lawyers for the McMichaels have said they chased Arbery because they suspected he was a burglar who had been recorded on video inside a nearby home under construction. They say Travis McMichael was fearing for his life when he shot Arbery as they grappled over a shotgun.

While the seating of a nearly all-white jury will likely be discussed by observers during the trial, it does not appear to be in violation of the jury selection process, and Walmsley’s approval is unlikely to lead to a mistrial or related appeals, legal experts following the case said.

The optics of it are "horrible," Page Pate, a Georgia defense attorney, said, but Walmsley ultimately "made the right ruling under Georgia law." 

Trial attorneys are allowed to reject potential jurors, known as peremptory challenges, and prosecutors and the defense can take turns eliminating people they don't like for virtually any reason. But they cannot strike a juror based solely on race, which the U.S. Supreme Court ruled unconstitutional in 1986 in Batson v. Kentucky.

An opposing attorney who believes someone was dismissed because of race can raise a "Batson" concern to the judge, who could force the other attorney to provide a "race-neutral" reason why a person was dropped.

Some 1,000 jury duty notices went out in Glynn County, where Arbery was killed on Feb. 23, 2020, not far from his home outside the small coastal city of Brunswick. Almost 200 potential jurors were then questioned before the pool was whittled to about 64 and then 48 as Walmsley permitted peremptory challenges.

On Tuesday, one of the defense attorneys, Kevin Gough, expressed skepticism over the pool of potential jurors, saying it lacked white men over 40 without a four-year college degree.

On Wednesday, as attorneys moved to select the 12 jurors and four alternates, Linda Dunikoski, a special prosecutor from the Cobb County District Attorney's Office, challenged the defense's attempt to cut eight Black people as potential jurors. Ultimately, 11 potential Black jurors were cut.

Defense attorney Laura Hogue told the judge she could give "a race-neutral reason for any one of these" and said some had presented strong opinions about the case, including a juror who had written on her questionnaire that she believed Arbery was shot "due to his color" and felt the defendants were guilty.

While Walmsley conceded that "quite a few African American jurors were excused through peremptory strikes executed by the defense," he ultimately agreed that each of their removals had a "legitimate, nondiscriminatory, clear, reasonably specific and related reason."

Chad Posick, a criminology and criminal justice professor at Georgia Southern University, said it might not appear fair, but "nothing at this point is illegal and the selection process was likely in line" with the standard.

University of California, Berkeley, study in 2020 found that prosecutors in hundreds of California appellate court trials examined from 2006 to 2018 used peremptory challenges to strike Black jurors from nearly 75 percent of cases and Latino jurors from about 28 percent of cases, while white jurors were removed from only 0.4 percent of cases.


A day that began with much optimism ended with a reminder that Newcastle is a club in need of huge change to compete at the top level.
0 comments
Two canceled main events led to a fight that underdelivered, and the UFC women's featherweight division beyond Amanda Nunes remains unclear.
0 comments
The armed gang, called 400 Mawozo, is holding 17 women, men and children from the US and Canada.
0 comments
Heavy rains cause rivers to overflow in Kerala, washing away homes and trapping people under debris.
0 comments
North Korea is criticizing Netflix's worldwide hit show "Squid Game," slamming it for highlighting the negative aspects of South Korean culture, including consumerism and inequality. CNN's Brian To...
0 comments
Newly released documents allege that Alex Murdaugh, a once-prominent South Carolina attorney now embroiled in scandals including alleged life insurance fraud, coordinated with his former housekeepe...
0 comments
The US alleges Saab was behind a corruption network involving a government-subsidized food program that stole hundreds of millions of dollars from the Venezuelan people. Saab's lawyer alleges his&h...
0 comments
Newly released documents allege that Alex Murdaugh, a once-prominent South Carolina attorney now embroiled in scandals including alleged life insurance fraud, coordinated with his former housekeepe...
0 comments
Thousands of demonstrators gathered in front of the presidential palace in Khartoum on Saturday calling for the military to seize power as Sudan grapples with the biggest political crisis in its tw...
0 comments
Romans are voting in a run-off election to decide the Italian capital's next mayor -- with a center-left or center-right candidate vying for the post.
0 comments
Washington State coach Nick Rolovich said he has not been updated on the status of his religious exemption request needed to be compliant with the state's COVID-19 vaccination mandate.
0 comments
In one of the biggest boxing upsets in recent memory, former four-division champion Mikey Garcia dropped a majority decision to underdog Sandor Martin on Saturday in Fresno, California.
0 comments
The kidnapped group includes five children, according to a statement by the Ohio-based Christian Aid Ministries on Sunday.
0 comments
The Russian film crew return after an ISS shoot that had its own moments of drama.
0 comments
At least 15 women, men and children were abducted by an armed gang near the capital, sources say.
0 comments
Two of Africa's Covid experts are clearing out their desks and counting the hours as they prepare to take up new roles offered to them overseas.
0 comments
The inaugural winners of Prince William's Earthshot Prize include the country of Costa Rica, an Indian organization that creates fuel from agricultural waste and a coral farming group in the Bahamas.
0 comments
A teenager triggered a large-scale police operation after a restaurant owner mistook a Lego toy gun he was carrying for a real weapon.
0 comments
After filming the first movie in space, Russian actress Yulia Peresild, producer-director Klim Shipenko and cosmonaut Oleg Novitskiy have returned to Earth. The trio landed in Kazakhstan at 12:35 a...
0 comments
Five United States citizens and a permanent resident who were serving house arrest in Caracas, Venezuela, were picked up by the country's intelligence service SEBIN on Saturday, just hours after th...
0 comments
Los Angeles County wants to compel the widow of NBA legend Kobe Bryant and others involved in a lawsuit over leaked photos of the helicopter crash that killed him, their daughter and seven others t...
0 comments
Myanmar's military junta said Saturday it was "extremely disappointed" with a decision by Southeast Asian foreign ministers to exclude its leader Min Aung Hlaing from an upcoming summit.
0 comments
Robert Durst, the notorious subject of the HBO docuseries "The Jinx," who was found guilty last month of first-degree murder and was sentenced earlier this week to life in prison without parole, ha...
0 comments
As many as 17 American missionaries have been reported kidnapped by gang members in Haiti on Saturday, including 14 adults and three minors, a source in Haiti's security forces told CNN.
0 comments
Former Heisman Trophy winner Lamar Jackson will join Johnny Unitas as the only football players in school history to have their numbers retired when Louisville celebrates his No. 8 on Nov. 13.
0 comments
David Baker, president and executive director of the Pro Football Hall of Fame, announced his retirement on Saturday.
0 comments
South East Asian countries decide not to invite the military coup leader to their meeting.
0 comments
Infections continue to soar as the Kremlin struggles to persuade people to get vaccinated.
0 comments
The city of Vienna is taking an offbeat approach to the censorship of art and has turned to using the adults-only online platform OnlyFans to put its most "explicit" artworks on full display.
0 comments
Russian President Vladimir Putin has been accused of making a sexist remark to a female journalist at an event this week. CNN's Sam Kiley reports.
0 comments
The pressure on Manchester United manager Ole Gunnar Solskjaer was ratcheted up a few notches on Saturday afternoon as his side lost 4-2 to Leicester City in the Premier League.
0 comments
Mohamed Salah scored his second wonderful solo goal in as many Premier League games as Liverpool spoilt Claudio Ranieri's return to management in the UK.
0 comments
With natural gas supplies running short on the continent, David A. Andelman writes that Russian President Vladimir Putin's ability to pressure Europe is only growing.
0 comments
Russia has reported a record number of Covid-19 cases and deaths in the past 24 hours, data from the country's Coronavirus Response Center showed Saturday.
0 comments
Demonstrations took place in several cities of Northern Italy on Monday, following new restrictions to curb the country's second wave of Covid.
0 comments
Workers of the world! Listen up.
0 comments
Loading...