States race to hand out billions in rent aid before federal deadline to use it or lose it

UniqueThis 50 Aug 19

Renters in most of the U.S. are protected from eviction until October 3. But the states and cities racing to distribute billions in aid to tenants who've fallen behind are facing a tighter deadline: They must get a large chunk of money out the door before the end of September, or risk having to give it back to the federal government.

Federal guidelines allow the U.S. Department of Treasury to claw back unused funding starting September 30 and reallocate it to other state and local programs that have used up at least 65% of their funding. That impending deadline worried some New York housing advocates, who fear the state could lose the rent aid if it is too slow in doling it out.

Jordan Dewbre, a staff attorney with BronxWorks, a nonprofit that helps both renters and landlords apply for aid, expressed concern that if the state doesn't distribute enough money to renters, "the Treasury can recoup those funds and allocate them somewhere else."

"That's a definite concern," Dewbre told CBS MoneyWatch. "Back in June, I was like, there's no way that would happen."

New York struggles to use rent relief funds 07:12

A Treasury official told CBS MoneyWatch that the goal of distributing 65% of the rental assistance by September 30 is only intended as a guideline to identify programs that could be eligible for additional funding — not a hard deadline for spending. The official added that the agency has encouraged states to use up the full financial allotment they received in the first round of Emergency Rental Assistance Funding. 

"The administration is laser-focused on encouraging jurisdictions to move the money more quickly, and they want to use the September 30 milestone — not 'deadline' — as an impetus for faster delivery of funds," said Stockton William, executive director of the National Council of State Housing Agencies, part of a group of organizations that urged flexibility on the September 30 date in a July letter.

While some states and counties are concerned about losing funds, Stockton suggested the Treasury Department would take a generous approach to assessing progress in distributing rent aid, looking at the total amount of money approved as well as the demand that programs had received — not just money that's been put in landlords' or renters' hands. 

If a program remains well below the 65% threshold when accounting for all the money in the pipeline, "I think Treasury will want to ask very focused questions and understand how the jurisdiction plan to accelerate funding, and what kind of demand it expects in the coming months," he said.

Money barely trickling

Plenty of states and cities have been slow to get renters money. Nine states — Alabama, Arkansas, Delaware, Mississippi, Nevada, South Carolina, North Dakota, South Dakota and Wyoming — have spent less than 3% of their rental assistance funds, according to the National Low-Income Housing Coalition, which tracks states' progress in disbursing funds.

Among large states, Florida has spent just 4% of the $870 million it was allocated in the first round of rental aid funding. Georgia has spent 3%, and Ohio has spent about 8%. Nationwide, only 20% of the first round of funding has made its way to renters, according to the NLIHC.

New York's program was among the last to kick off, launching on June 1, and the first payments did not go out to renters until July 19. For some weeks, the state seemed in danger of missing the timeline.

But after pushing through thousands of applications, the state seems to have cleared that hurdle, Michael Hein, commissioner of New York's Office of Temporary and Disability Assistance, testified on Thursday. (The OTDA runs the statewide rent-help program.)

"New York has surpassed the Treasury's 65% threshold to avoid a clawback of funds," Hein told the New York State Senate. "I can guarantee you, we are confident we have already surpassed that number … there will not be a clawback of funds," he said.

Just over $150 million, or about 12% of the first round of funding, has made it into renters' hands, according to OTDA figures. The state has also approved another $680 million to be paid out, but is waiting for property owners to agree to take the money.

Application process causing "anxiety"

OTDA recently rolled out improvements to the aid application, making it easier for applicants to check their status and to save and resume an application.

For months, community groups have blasted the Empire State's online-only application process, calling it cumbersome, opaque and unconscionably slow in getting the money to desperate renters.

"We can't troubleshoot any issues, we can't check the status, see where the application is, if it's pending, if it needs more information. We don't get notification if an application was denied or approved," Lakisha Morris, who directs the rental assistance program for Catholic Charities in New York City, told CBS MoneyWatch. 

"It's generating significant anxiety for tenants," Xing Hui Zheng, assistant director of University Settlement, said in an email. "What's going to happen to tenants who already have eviction cases in court? The NYC eviction moratorium ends on August 31," she said.

(The U.S. Supreme Court on Thursday blocked part of New York's eviction moratorium and allowed landlords to challenge in local courts their tenants' declarations of economic hardship.)

COVID concerns over ending eviction ban 06:18

Smaller programs already tapped out

At the other end of the spectrum, some local housing programs have already run through their first batch of rent funding, and are anxiously awaiting more.  

The City of Los Angeles stopped accepting rent aid applications on April 30, citing "unprecedented demand that far exceeded the program funding." The rental aid program in Tucson and Pima county, Arizona, has so far heard from about 16,000 renters, and "it continues to grow," according to Meghan Heddings, executive director of Family Housing Resources, one of the participating nonprofits. 

The local program to date has sent out $21 million in aid — nearly double the amount that the state of Arizona has distributed in counties that don't have local programs.

"Our state was awarded $200 million and much less was brought to the local [program]," Heddings told CBS MoneyWatch. "Is there a way for them to provide more funds to us? I'm hopeful that request will be made. We've proven that we know our community and we can get those funds out."


Most Popular